Skip to main content

Cherry Lemonade Beach Pie

Cherry Lemonade Pie with a slice taken out and put to the side
Photograph by Isa Zapata, Prop Styling by Sean Dooley, Food Styling by Kendra Vaculin

A beach pie—like the kind popularized by Bill Smith at Crook’s Corner in Chapel Hill, North Carolina—should be very simple. To me the name indicates a dessert to make on vacation, in a rented house with limited kitchen tools at your disposal. This version, inspired by the cherry lemonade at Hot Dog on a Stick (the perfect summer mall drink, IMO), is made almost entirely with shelf-stable ingredients that you can throw in the back of your car for the drive to the shore; the only items that require refrigeration from the jump are eggs and butter.

Don’t hesitate to make this recipe your own: You can use whatever crackers or cookies you want for the crust. I like saltines for their stiff structure that makes cutting clean slices a breeze, but the buttery crunch of Ritz with a tart, creamy lemon filling is great too. Just be sure to not skip the added salt; even an already salty cracker needs the bump once you add all that sugar and butter. And if cherries aren’t your thing, use a different jam and fruit. Strawberry jam with sliced strawberries around the edges, blackberry jam with plump blackberries dotting the surface—it’s all good.

What you’ll need

Read More
Cut this easy-to-handle dough (thanks, cream cheese) into wide strips for a fast-forming lattice that stuns.
The zest of three whole lemons gives these cookies a no-holds-barred citrus flavor.
These bright cheesecake bars feature spring’s favorite flavor duo and a Triscuit cracker crust.
Transform puff pastry, ripe fruit, and a slick of jam into a patisserie-chic dessert.
This is the perfect summer party dessert, featuring grilled pound cake, Cointreau-spiked raspberries, and classic vanilla ice cream.
The best fruit pie, complete with a brown sugar streusel topping.
Legendary pastry chef Claudia Fleming wraps both sweet and sour cherries into these flaky handheld treats.
Inspired by Wayne Thiebaud’s iconic Cake Slice, these three distinct layers start with one simple batter.